Recommend NeutralOdishaNews.com to your network!

Pros vs Cons of Ethanol Blending

Pros (Benefits)	Cons (Concerns)
Reduces crude oil imports → saves ₹30k–35k crore annually	⛽ Mileage drops by 6–10% in vehicles on E20
🌍 Cuts CO₂ emissions by 15–20%	🔧🚜 Older vehicles (pre-2020) face engine wear & corrosion
Cleaner combustion → less particulate matter & CO	🚫 No option for consumers to choose pure petrol (E0)
Boosts farmer income (sugarcane & maize demand)	💧 High water usage for sugarcane (~2860L per 1L ethanol)
⚡ Encourages biofuel industry & energy security	🌾 Food security risk if grains diverted for fuel

1. What is Ethanol Blending?

Ethanol is an alcohol-based fuel (C₂H₅OH) usually made from sugarcane, corn, or other biomass.
Blending means mixing ethanol with petrol (gasoline) to reduce crude oil imports, cut emissions, and support farmers.
Example: If you mix 10% ethanol with 90% petrol, that’s E10 fuel.

2. What are E5 and E20?

E5 → Petrol with 5% ethanol.
E10 → Petrol with 10% ethanol (already standard across India since 2022).
E20 → Petrol with 20% ethanol (rollout started in 2023; full target by 2025–26).

3. Why are some Indians opposing ethanol blending?

The pushback comes from multiple angles:

a) Mileage & Performance Concerns

Ethanol has lower energy content (~30% less than petrol).
Vehicles running on higher ethanol blends can see 5–10% lower mileage (fuel efficiency).
For many middle-class Indians, this directly affects their fuel cost per km.

Ethanol blending was pushed by the concerned Minister Nitin Gadkari, surprisingly his 2 sons are suppliers of Ethanol, clear case of conflict of interest and quid pro quo – Details Here

b) Vehicle Compatibility

Not all existing vehicles are designed to handle higher ethanol blends.
Rubber, plastic, and certain metals in older engines can corrode with ethanol, leading to higher maintenance.

c) No Option at the Pump

Unlike some countries where you can choose (E0, E10, E20, E85), Indian fuel stations largely have only one blend nationwide.
So customers cannot opt for pure petrol (E0/E5) if they wish.

d) Food vs Fuel Debate

Ethanol production needs sugarcane, maize, or rice → critics argue it can divert food crops, raise water usage, and impact food security.

e) Price Transparency

Petrol price at pumps doesn’t reduce even though ethanol is cheaper than crude oil.
Citizens feel they aren’t sharing the cost benefit, only the downsides.

4. How does ethanol blending affect vehicles?

Short-term: Vehicles generally tolerate up to E10 with minimal issues.
E20 effects:
- Mileage drops ~6–10%
- Engine wear can increase if the vehicle is not designed for it
- Cold-start problems (ethanol absorbs water, harder ignition in winter)
- More frequent servicing of fuel lines and filters may be required

5. Which models in India support E20?

As per SIAM (Society of Indian Automobile Manufacturers) and automakers:

Most cars/bikes manufactured after April 2023 are E20 material-compliant (fuel lines, seals, etc. resistant to ethanol).
Flex-fuel vehicles (which can run up to E85) are being planned, but few models are in the market.
Older vehicles (before 2020) → mostly safe up to E10 only.

Examples:

Maruti Suzuki: New models since 2022–23 (Swift, Baleno, Brezza, WagonR) certified for E20.
Hyundai: Creta, i20, Venue new versions are E20-ready.
Two-wheelers: Honda, TVS, Bajaj new bikes post-2022 designed for E20.

6. Why aren’t Indians given fuel-choice options?

Logistics: Maintaining multiple storage tanks (E0, E10, E20) at every pump is costly.
Policy: Government has mandated uniform rollout of ethanol blends (first E10, now E20) to simplify supply chains.
Market: Oil Marketing Companies (IOCL, HPCL, BPCL) supply one standard blend → customers can’t pick.

7. Research in Support of Ethanol Blending

NITI Aayog & Indian Oil studies:
- E20 could save India ₹30,000–35,000 crore annually in crude imports.
- Reduces CO₂ emissions by 15–20% compared to pure petrol.
Health angle: Ethanol burns cleaner, reduces particulate matter and carbon monoxide.
Farmer income boost: More demand for sugarcane & maize helps agro-economy.

8. Research/Criticism Against Ethanol Blending

IIT Kanpur study (2022): Vehicles on E20 showed 6–7% fuel efficiency loss.
Automakers’ caution: Older vehicles risk engine wear, corrosion.
Water usage concern: Sugarcane ethanol consumes huge water → ~2,860 liters of water per liter of ethanol (in India’s drought-prone regions, this is a problem).
Food security risk: Diverting grains like rice/maize for ethanol could affect food subsidies (PDS).

In summary:
Ethanol blending is meant to cut imports, help farmers, and reduce pollution. But opposition is growing because Indians feel: